Fording River Extension Project

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Stephen Nelson
• Reference number: 456
• Submitted: 2026-02-18 - 6:46 PM
• Project phase: Impact Statement
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Care about animals

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Beaconsfield Animal Services
• Reference number: 424
• Submitted: 2026-02-15 - 11:57 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• I noticed a lot of wildlife live here.  ?????Please preserve the trees at this location. Please do not harm animals with this project. Please do not use animal testing for pollution and effluent monitoring. https://www.change.org/p/stop-testing-sewer-water-on-laboratory-fish ?Please work with the Canadian Centre for the Alternatives to Animal Methods. https://www.uwindsor.ca/ccaam/ Please only use non lethal ways to live with geese, beavers, and other wildlife. Develop a Living With Coyotes program with the animal welfare organization Coyote Watch Canada. www.coyotewatchcanada.com Please only use non lethal ways to manage wildlife. There are humane, non lethal ways to deal with beavers. Here's a great resource. https://thefurbearers.com/downloads/PDFs/Beaver%20Book%20-%202019-10-08%20The%20Fur-Bearers.pdf?fbclid=IwAR1fP2wOYQKbWREX0E5QzYBhZLf9VjwMov3p37Vh8ToW1-NeQvAoVATZhEg%0A%0A https://www.change.org/p/stop-banff-from-killing-animals-after-conflicts https://www.humanesociety.org/resources/humanely-scare-away-canada-geese https://www.canadageese.org/nlcontrol.html https://www.peta.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/humane-goose-control-pdf.pdf https://www.humanesociety.org/resources/what-do-about-canada-geese This company makes non lethal products. https://margosupplies.com/ca-en/ ? Conventional rodent control uses cruel methods. The companies use glue traps, and snap traps, which, like legholds, can cause injury. They also use rodenticide, which kills slowly and kills many non target ...

Report

Attachment Unnecessary polution

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Don Holland
• Reference number: 469
• Submitted: 2026-02-14 - 11:34 AM
• Project phase: Impact Statement
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• You need to stop sending your mining crap to the USA...pause permitting process for Fording River mine expansion  NOW...get your Elk Valley pollution under control....make sure ALL previous joint international recommendations are implemented and evaluated...get real on selenium standards at .080p/lis DO IT and quit wallowing.

Report

Attachment Re: EVR Project 80702

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Mike Goleski
• Reference number: 423
• Submitted: 2026-02-13 - 10:34 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Greetings; Three pillars of any development need to be a balance of social, economic, and ecological benefits. I have no idea how this new development is going to play out , however my recommendation is for EVR to purchase properties along the Elk River and significant fish spawning creeks, between Fording River and Elko to the equivalent of 33.3% of their total held property/mining rights in the Elk Valley. The purpose of these new property purchases would be to enhance and protect the natural heritage of the Elk River watershed for all residents and visitors to appreciate and recreate in perpetuity. These properties should be purchased with the Elk Valley's First Nations input and management. A board of directors from these First Nations as well as all the valley's Outdoor sports alliances and Wildsight would ensure the successs of this venture. So that said, if this new development, or if any other future development is approved, then the deal is they are to purchase new Elk River (or watershed) properties to add to the growing watershed protection areas and natural enhancement holdings. Please consider this idea. Thank you for reviewing all these comments from the public.

Report

Attachment FRX Comment Submission and Review Panel Request

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Wildsight
• Reference number: 422
• Submitted: 2026-02-13 - 8:28 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Hello,   Please see the attached comment submission and review panel request letter, thank you for your consideration.    
• Attachment included
• To: Impact Assessment Agency of Canada (IAAC) Project: Fording River Extension Project (Reference No. 80702) Subject: Formal Submission on the Draft Federal Appendix and Joint Assessment and Engagement Plan We thank you for the opportunity to provide feedback on the Fording River Extension Project’s (the “Project”) Joint Assessment and Engagement plan and Application Information Requirements draft federal Appendix. Below are summaries of our biggest concerns and a request for these issues to be addressed via an independent review panel. There is no dispute the Project is exceptionally large. The Agency acknowledged as much in its 2020 Analysis Report. The well documented likelihood for the Project to cause adverse impacts in areas of federal jurisdiction necessitate a thorough, comprehensive and transparent process involving an independent review panel. Incorporating the suggestions set out in this letter are critical to achieve that goal. Expansion of Indigenous Inclusion On September 19th 2025, the BC EAO released letters to the Kainai, Piikani, Siksika, and Stoney Nakoda Nations, notifying them that they have been assessed as requiring consultation commensurate with the “low end of the Haida spectrum”. This includes notification and consultation at specific milestones, but goes further and includes language meant to exclude them from “economic accommodations or co-management arrangements”. These nations exist mainly in Alberta, but historically have used and occupied areas of BC, including the Elk Valley. These letters from the EAO limit consultation requirements, raising doubts about the legitimacy of the provincial environmental assessment procedure. This further accentuates the need ...

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Mine Extension

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: North Fork Preservation Association
• Reference number: 383
• Submitted: 2026-02-13 - 1:46 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• The North Fork Preservation Association (NFPA) appreciates the opportunity to comment on the proposed Fording River Extension (FRX) of the Fording River coal mine by Elk Valley Resources (EVR), situated in the Elk River watershed of British Columbia. Geographically, the Elk River Valley is next door to the Canadian Flathead River Valley which becomes the North Fork of the Flathead River Valley once it crosses the international boundary and enters the State of Montana.   NFPA is a conservation organization which focuses on the North Fork of the Flathead River Valley. The mission of the NFPA is to champion the exceptional biodiversity and wildness of the North Fork of the Flathead River watershed in Northwest Montana. The North Fork of the Flathead River Valley is bordered on the east by Glacier National Park (GNP) and on the west by federal and state public land; only 4 percent of the valley is privately held. As such it is part of the Crown of the Continent, one of the largest intact ecosystems remaining on the North American Continent. It is a refuge for many threatened and endangered species, including grizzly bears, wolverine, lynx, bull trout and many species of concern. The NFPA, along with U.S. Senators Max Baucus and Jon Tester, were instrumental in the long-term effort to protect the North Fork of the Flathead River drainage in Montana from mining and oil and gas development in the Canadian Flathead River Valley, culminating in the passage of the 2014 North Fork Watershed Protection Act.   Given the above efforts, we have considerable concern regarding the well documented selenium and nitrate contamination in the nearby Elk River Valley. Waste rock from Elk River ...

Report

Attachment Fording River expansion by Elk Valley Resources

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Gary Aitken
• Reference number: 452
• Submitted: 2026-02-13 - 12:28 AM
• Project phase: Impact Statement
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• To Whom it may Concern,   Please deny any expansion of mining in the Elk River watershed. This watershed already has excessive levels of Selenium. The owner of these mines, Glencore, is a Swiss multinational commodities trader known for shady business practices and the mines are notorious for pollution. Montana's Lake Koocanusa is already above the legal limit for selenium.   Please deny any mining expansion at least until current pollution is mitigated.   Thank you

Report

Attachment Please pause the permitting process of the Fording River Mine Expansion

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Karen Seashore & Tom Tillisch
• Reference number: 344
• Submitted: 2026-02-13
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Members of the International Joint Commission We urge you carefully consider mining pollution in our watershed before Glencore commits further damage. Mine expansions before this work is finished will undermine the entire effort. The IJC is overseeing a process of developing long-term recommendations that incorporate both western science and indigenous knowledge, to address mining pollution in this watershed. Approving mine expansions before this work is complete would undermine the entire effort. Future generations, as well as our current populations of humans and other creatures, require this consideration. Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Pause permitting for the Fording River Mine Expansion

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Wendy Graham
• Reference number: 401
• Submitted: 2026-02-13
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• I am writing on behalf of North Idaho's river system, urging you to pause the permitting process for the Fording River Mine Expansion until: The completed recommendations of the International Joint Commission (IJC) are fully implemented and evaluated. Pollution from existing Elk Valley mines is proven to be under long-term control. Montana’s selenium standard of 0.8 µg/L is consistently met at the international border. Downstream communities, Tribes, fisheries, and local economies in Montana and Idaho are fully protected from harm. The Kootenai Tribe of Idaho and other affected Tribes and First Nations have given their free, prior, and informed consent, and their concerns about water, fish, and cultural impacts have been fully addressed. Strong, enforceable safeguards are in place to protect shared waters for future generations.   Thanks for your consideration, 

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Lena Olson
• Reference number: 328
• Submitted: 2026-02-12 - 2:38 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine.   I grew up fishing Lake Koocanusa and can say first hand that the fish populations are not abundant as they were 20 years ago. On a recent fishing trip with my father, we decided to research our observations, only to find that the selenium levels in the reservoir were directly impacting the fish population.   The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   Montana is transitioning from an extractive economy to a tourism economy.  Almost all of our watersheds have been contaminated by industry, leaving our rural communities suffering both economically and in degraded public health, and the tax-payers footing the bill for companies that won't hold themselves accountable. It has come to my attention that the Swiss company responsible for Elk Valley Coal mines has yet to address multiple encounters and policy ...

Report

Attachment Proposed Fording River Mine Expansion

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Charles E. Corsi
• Reference number: 403
• Submitted: 2026-02-12 - 2:28 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• RE:  Propose Glencore Mine Expansion of the Fording River Mine   The Panhandle Chapter of Trout Unlimited (PCTU), based in northern Idaho, is comprised of over 250 members.  PCTU is committed to the Trout Unlimited mission to protect, restore and sustain cold water fisheries and their watersheds that sustain them.  The Kootenai River watershed, headwatered in British Columbia, supports highly valued native fish populations and sport fisheries.  Fish populations in the Kootenai River in Idaho include native species that are protected under the Endangered Species Act (U.S.), and other native fishes which provide valuable sport fisheries and are the focus of other conservation efforts. Because water quality science, decisions and management in British Columbia affect cold water fisheries habitat, water quality, and populations downstream in Idaho, we offer the following comments on the proposed Fording River mine expansion:   It is our understanding the proposed mine expansion would open up nearly 5,000 acres (nearly 2000 hectares) to mine development.  Coal mining operations in the upper Kootenai River basin are already responsible for elevated selenium levels in the Kootenai River. Selenium concerns exist downstream on the Kootenai River into Idaho, where water quality studies have identified elevated levels high enough to pose concerns about negative impacts to reproductive success and health of native fishes, including federally listed (“Endangered”) Kootenai River white sturgeon.  Selenium can and will negatively impact Kootenai River salmonids (bull trout, rainbow/redband trout, westslope cutthroat trout, kokanee, and mountain ...

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Sara Toubman
• Reference number: 396
• Submitted: 2026-02-12 - 1:22 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province. Why not be a good neighbor? Please do not pollute our waterways.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Ford River Expansion harm

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Patricia Bradley
• Reference number: 468
• Submitted: 2026-02-12 - 1:18 PM
• Project phase: Impact Statement
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Please DO NOT allow more expansion of mining at Ford River.  This would further harm the Kootenai watershed with contamination of selenium pollution.  Is not the safe future of our kids and our country more important than profit by a Swiss headquarters Glencore who is already identified as corrupt??  PLEASE -- NO ! Thank you.

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Kathy Ross
• Reference number: 405
• Submitted: 2026-02-12 - 12:46 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Elk Valley Coal Expansion

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Roy O'Connor
• Reference number: 340
• Submitted: 2026-02-12 - 12:40 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Sirs, I am very concerned about additional pollution flowing into Montana rivers, pollution than originates anywhere including locally and in British Columbia.  We know this is happening in our Elk River, with Selenium levels coming in from BC impacting our water quality.  It is lowering fish health and numbers, and threatening a large recreation industry as well. Please refrain from permitting this expansion until a remedy has been found and implemented to control and eventually stop this pollution. Thanks for considering this,  Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Joel Vignere
• Reference number: 408
• Submitted: 2026-02-12 - 11:48 AM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Evelyn Nadison
• Reference number: 346
• Submitted: 2026-02-12 - 11:48 AM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Sherry Bromley
• Reference number: 462
• Submitted: 2026-02-12 - 11:46 AM
• Project phase: Impact Statement
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Steven Martinez
• Reference number: 407
• Submitted: 2026-02-12 - 10:30 AM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Curtis Kruer
• Reference number: 425
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 11:08 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Michael King
• Reference number: 357
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 10:24 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Janet Childress
• Reference number: 358
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 10:18 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Claire Baiz c/o Reicherts
• Reference number: 373
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 9:00 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of John E Dunkum
• Reference number: 336
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 8:56 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Joanne Morrow
• Reference number: 410
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 8:52 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the United States who resides in northwest Montana and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment my Indigenous neighbors of the  Ksanka Band of the Ktunaxa/Kootenai Nation, on our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Stephen Motsco
• Reference number: 389
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 7:52 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Janice Lee
• Reference number: 351
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 7:04 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Jackie Foster
• Reference number: 337
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 6:14 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of robin vogler
• Reference number: 415
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 4:54 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Julie Chapman
• Reference number: 406
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 4:26 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I have been cheering on Canada in many areas as you stand up to Trump and to the awfulness of his regime...but I am unpleasantly surprised that you would consider expanding a mine that is already in need of mitigation and that is so badly polluting.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Dennis Heinzig
• Reference number: 352
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 4:22 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Shanti Devins
• Reference number: 414
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 4:00 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Raso Hultgren
• Reference number: 347
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 3:30 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of JL Angell
• Reference number: 467
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 3:00 PM
• Project phase: Impact Statement
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Charlene Woodcock
• Reference number: 458
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 2:54 PM
• Project phase: Impact Statement
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   Canadian mining corporations are infamous around the world for the environmental damage they commit.   As a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine, I ask that you NOT add to this damage!   The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Wayne Tomicich
• Reference number: 461
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 2:52 PM
• Project phase: Impact Statement
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Sarah Moody
• Reference number: 353
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 2:48 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment British Columbia Mining Pollution

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Rachel Rockafellow
• Reference number: 338
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 2:42 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• For years, massive open-pit coal mines in the Elk Valley of British Columbia have been leaching toxic levels of selenium into the Elk River, which flows into Lake Koocanusa and the Kootenai River in Montana and Idaho. The mines are owned by Glencore, a Swiss-headquartered multinational commodities trader that has a well-known reputation for corruption, bribery, and environmental damage. Lake Koocanusa is well above the legal limit for selenium in the waters – at levels that threaten fish populations and aquatic life. Now, the province of British Columbia is considering a permit to allow for an expansion of mining activities (https://can01.safelinks.protection.outlook.com) is trying to decide how to mitigate and prevent the current pollution. The expansion of Fording River would allow for Elk Valley Resources (EVR), the company proposing the expansion, to expand the mine by an additional 5,000 acres, which would only exacerbate the already dire selenium pollution issue in Koocanusa and the Kootenai watershed.   I protest and beg that you not permit this mining.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Jackson Scholl
• Reference number: 331
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 2:36 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Tarn Ream
• Reference number: 359
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 2:12 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Lynn Tennefoss
• Reference number: 426
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 1:46 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Jane Whetzel
• Reference number: 333
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 1:36 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Luca Welle
• Reference number: 355
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 1:34 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Kathie Daviau
• Reference number: 413
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 1:29 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Sandy Kindt
• Reference number: 354
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 1:24 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of O. Alan Weltzien
• Reference number: 339
• Submitted: 2026-02-11 - 1:18 PM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir)and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province.   Sincerely,

Report

Attachment Fording River Mine Expansion

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Jake Hagadone
• Reference number: 470
• Submitted: 2026-02-10 - 1:37 PM
• Project phase: Impact Statement
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Hello,  I am writing you to ask you to please pause the permitting process for the Fording River Mine Expansion until:    -The completed recommendations of the Internal Joint Commission are fully implemented and evaluated.    -Pollution from existing Elk Valley mines are proven to be under long term control.     -Montana's selenium standard of 8 ug/L is consistently met at the international border.   -Downstream Tribes, communities, fisheries, and local economies in Montana and Idaho are fully protected from harm.   -The Kootenai Tribe and other affected Tribes and First Nations have given thir free, prior, and informed consent and their concerns about water, fisheries, and cultural impacts have been fully addressed.   -Strong, enforceable safeguards are in place to protect shared waters for future generations.   Thank you, 

Report

Attachment Comment on Fording River Extension project

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Ashley Fischer
• Reference number: 404
• Submitted: 2026-02-10 - 9:18 AM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• Dear Impact Assessment Agency of Canada:   I write as a citizen of the U.S. and downstream neighbor of the Elk Valley mines, including the Fording River Mine. The mines in the Elk Valley leach toxic levels of selenium into the Elk Valley, as you well know, but that pollution flows south into Montana's Lake Koocanusa (Koocanusa Reservoir) and Kootenai(y) River at levels that are out of compliance with Montana law. These are not just standards on paper, but are standards developed to protect aquatic life and ecosystems from harm. Authorizing the Fording River expansion would have a significant, negative impact on Montana's environment, our economy, and our outdoor way of life.   I firmly request a halt to the permitting of the Elk Valley Coal mines until the province has addressed, mitigated, and reduced existing selenium contamination, as mine expansions and additional mines will only increase the amount of pollutants in our waterways.   Everyone should know at this time in history that all of our actions have consequences.  Many of these consequences will last for generations to come. Many start to affect us immediately. Stop thinking in the short term and about your own personal and corporate gains. Start thinking about the future of everyone. It is sad that this world no longer has empathy for our fellow neighbors and this needs to change immediately.   Further, I request that you share these comments with the province. ...

Report

Attachment Fording River Mine Expansion

• Fording River Extension Project
• Author: Administrator on behalf of Richard Birkett
• Reference number: 400
• Submitted: 2026-02-10 - 7:55 AM
• Project phase: Planning
• Participation notice: Public notice - Public comments invited on the draft guidelines and plans
• I am writing to you to urge decision-makers to pause the permitting process for the Fording River Mine Expansion until: The completed recommendations of the International Joint Commission (IJC) are fully implemented and evaluated. Pollution from existing Elk Valley mines is proven to be under long-term control. Montana’s selenium standard of 0.8 µg/L is consistently met at the international border. Downstream communities, Tribes, fisheries, and local economies in Montana and Idaho are fully protected from harm. The Kootenai Tribe of Idaho and other affected Tribes and First Nations have given their free, prior, and informed consent, and their concerns about water, fish, and cultural impacts have been fully addressed. Strong, enforceable safeguards are in place to protect shared waters for future generations. I am a resident of Idaho, an active fly fisher and President of the North Idaho Fly Casters.  We aren't a big organization, but we do fish on the Kootenai River which has been affected by pollution from mining.  We are concerned that mining companies come and go, leaving lethal waste behind that has killed our fish and threatened drinking water.  There are a number of sites in our North Idaho area where we are still faced with cleanup of pollution that is over 100 years old.  Please do not automatically approve this without these clear and reliable measures in place.  Thank you.

Report